Coming-of-age rituals — what we kept, what we lost

Arnold van Gennep's 1909 The Rites of Passage argued that life-stage transitions across cultures share a common structure: separation (the initiate is removed from ordinary life), transition or liminality (the initiate exists outside normal categories), and incorporation (the initiate returns with new status). The structure applies to coming-of-age but also to weddings, funerals, and changes of social rank. The pattern's universality across unrelated cultures suggests it tracks something about how human social cognition assimilates change: status transitions need a marker, a process, and a confirmation, or they do not stick.

Victor Turner extended van Gennep's framework by focusing on what happens in the liminal phase. Turner observed that during liminality, normal hierarchies are suspended; initiates are treated as equals to each other and as social non-persons to the outside world. They form intense horizontal bonds (communitas) that often persist for life. The liminal phase is also where esoteric knowledge is transmitted, where ordeals are imposed, and where the initiate's identity is broken down and rebuilt. The intensity is the point. A liminal phase without intensity does not produce transformation; it produces a long weekend.

Maasai male initiation traditionally involved several stages over roughly fifteen years. Boys around 12–16 underwent circumcision and entered the warrior (moran) age-set. After a long period as warriors, they underwent eunoto, the ceremony marking the end of warriorhood and entry into junior elderhood. The eunoto involved shaving of the long warrior braids by the warrior's mother, ritual feasting, and incorporation into the elder council. The structure transitioned the man through three distinct status phases (boy, warrior, elder) with three distinct ceremonies. Contemporary Maasai life has compressed or eliminated several of these phases, with consequences for community structure that elders openly mourn.

The Jewish bar mitzvah (and the more recent bat mitzvah, which developed in the twentieth century) has proved unusually durable. The ceremony requires real preparation (Hebrew reading, Torah portion, dvar Torah), real performance before the community, and confers real religious obligations. It is supported by a religious institution that has resisted the privatization of life-cycle rituals. It is also frequently commercialized into a luxury party, which is the form most non-Jews encounter, but the underlying ritual structure has resisted that commercialization more than most. The bar mitzvah works because it has not been hollowed out.

The quinceañera, marking a girl's fifteenth birthday in many Latin American traditions, has survived and even expanded among Latino communities in the U.S. It blends Spanish Catholic elements (Mass, blessing) with indigenous and modern elements (court of honor, choreographed dance, formal dress). It is firmly a community event, with godparents, sponsors, and extended kin playing assigned roles. Like the bar mitzvah, it has been commercialized but retains structural integrity. It marks girls more clearly than American culture marks them, and the cultural persistence suggests the function is wanted.

Japan's coming-of-age day (seijin no hi), held in January for everyone turning 20 in the past year, is a state-organized ritual where young adults wear formal traditional dress, attend local ceremonies, and receive recognition from municipal officials. It is uneven in seriousness — some participants treat it as a photo opportunity — but it preserves the community-recognition function. Notably, Japan lowered the legal age of majority to 18 in 2022 without immediately moving the seijin shiki, indicating that the ritual age and the legal age can be allowed to diverge if the ritual is doing real work.

Christian confirmation, marking the young person's affirmation of baptismal vows, was once a major life-cycle event in Western Europe. It has weakened along with religious participation generally. In Lutheran Scandinavia it persists as a cultural ritual (with extensive gifts and celebrations) even among non-religious families, suggesting that the form survives demand for the function even after the theology has receded. In American Catholic and Protestant settings, confirmation rates have dropped and the ceremony has lost cultural weight. The remaining religious traditions that confirm seriously (Mormon missions, some Orthodox practices) tend to involve real difficulty and real status change.

Aboriginal Australian walkabout, in which young men spent extended periods alone in the bush as a transition to adulthood, has been romanticized and partly invented by outside observers. The actual practices were more varied and more embedded in community than the popular image suggests. But the underlying logic — adult status requires that the young person prove they can survive without immediate community support — has been borrowed by Western wilderness programs (Outward Bound, NOLS, vision-quest retreats). These work, when they work, because they preserve the separation-liminality-return structure even when they import it onto a foreign cultural base.

Military basic training is one of the strongest surviving coming-of-age rituals in modern Western societies. It separates the initiate (induction, shaved head, uniform, new name), imposes intense liminality (extreme physical demands, sleep deprivation, communitas with other recruits, isolation from outside contacts), and reincorporates with new status (graduation, return as a soldier). The transformation is real and acknowledged. The ritual is also embedded in an institution with specific purposes, which means it produces soldiers, not adults in general. But the structural similarity to traditional initiation is unmistakable, and the fact that it works partly explains the persistent appeal of military service as a coming-of-age path.

Defending traditional rituals as a category runs into the problem of practices that are harmful by any reasonable standard. Female genital cutting, practiced in coming-of-age contexts in parts of Africa and the Middle East, has been the most contested case. The ritual-defense argument — that the practice marks status, integrates the girl into the community of women, and should not be judged by external standards — has lost ground to medical and human rights arguments. The cutting is being slowly suppressed, with mixed success. The displacement has not, however, produced replacement rituals that preserve the social function, and some communities report a loss of intergenerational connection alongside the welcome end of physical harm.

When formal coming-of-age rituals weaken, informal substitutes appear. Street gangs in many American and Latin American cities run their own initiations: tests of courage, violent acts that mark commitment, induction into a fictive family with new names and obligations. These are functioning rituals in van Gennep's terms: separation, liminality, incorporation. They confer real status, supply real communitas, and demand real loyalty. That they are destructive does not mean they are not doing ritual work; it means the demand for ritual work is being met by destructive providers because the constructive providers have withdrawn.

Michael Wessells's work on child soldier reintegration in Sierra Leone, Angola, and Mozambique documented that community ritual cleansing ceremonies — feeding the returned combatant special foods, having elders speak over them, sometimes physical washing or naming — were more effective than Western individual trauma therapy. The community ritual told the young person and everyone around them that the soldier-identity had been left behind and the civilian-identity restored. This is ritual technology applied to one of the hardest transitions imaginable, and it worked because it engaged the structural elements van Gennep identified.

A serious attempt to rebuild coming-of-age rituals in wealthy modern societies would need: a substantive separation (weeks or months, not a weekend); a liminal phase involving genuine difficulty and communitas with other initiates; non-parental elders who participate in the recognition; a real test that can be passed or failed; and a community moment of incorporation that confers visible new status. Some existing institutions approximate this (military service, certain religious gap years, some wilderness programs, university residential life at its strongest). Most do not. Designing replacement rituals that are voluntary, secular, non-destructive, and serious is hard, and we have not collectively tried very hard. The cost of not trying is being absorbed by individual young people, one at a time.

1. van Gennep, Arnold. The Rites of Passage. Translated by Monika B. Vizedom and Gabrielle L. Caffee. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1960 [1909]. 2. Turner, Victor. The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. Chicago: Aldine, 1969. 3. Turner, Victor. The Forest of Symbols: Aspects of Ndembu Ritual. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1967. 4. Wessells, Michael. Child Soldiers: From Violence to Protection. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2006. 5. Eliade, Mircea. Rites and Symbols of Initiation: The Mysteries of Birth and Rebirth. New York: Harper & Row, 1958. 6. Bettelheim, Bruno. Symbolic Wounds: Puberty Rites and the Envious Male. Glencoe, IL: Free Press, 1954. 7. Herdt, Gilbert, ed. Rituals of Manhood: Male Initiation in Papua New Guinea. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1982. 8. Spencer, Paul. The Maasai of Matapato: A Study of Rituals of Rebellion. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1988. 9. Boddy, Janice. Civilizing Women: British Crusades in Colonial Sudan. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2007. 10. Davila, Arlene. Latinos, Inc.: The Marketing and Making of a People. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2001. 11. Grimes, Ronald L. Deeply into the Bone: Re-Inventing Rites of Passage. Berkeley: University of California Press, 2000. 12. Mahdi, Louise Carus, Steven Foster, and Meredith Little, eds. Betwixt and Between: Patterns of Masculine and Feminine Initiation. La Salle, IL: Open Court, 1987.